Does Schedule 3 Affect Your Visa Application? Understanding the Risks and Practical Solutions

When applying for an Australian visa onshore, one of the most complex legal hurdles applicants may face is Schedule 3 of the Migration Regulations 1994.
This regulation is often misunderstood, yet it can be the deciding factor between a successful visa grant and a refusal — particularly for those who are unlawful non-citizens or hold bridging visas at the time of application.

In this article, we’ll break down what Schedule 3 means, why it exists, who it affects, and most importantly, how you can respond strategically if it applies to your situation.

What Is Schedule 3 and Why Does It Exist?

Schedule 3 sets out additional criteria that certain onshore visa applicants must meet if they are not holding a substantive visa at the time they apply.

In other words, if you’re applying for a visa while your previous visa has expired (and you’re on a bridging visa or unlawful), Schedule 3 applies.
Its main purpose is to discourage people from staying in Australia after their visa expires, then applying for another visa to remain onshore.

The key principle:

Only applicants with valid, lawful status should normally be eligible to apply for visas while in Australia — unless there are compelling reasons to allow otherwise.

Who Is Affected by Schedule 3?

You may be affected by Schedule 3 if:

• You no longer hold a substantive visa (e.g. your student, partner, or skilled visa has expired), and
• You apply for a new onshore visa, such as a partner visa, protection visa, or certain skilled visas.

In practice, Schedule 3 most commonly applies to partner visa applicants (subclass 820), protection visa applicants, and occasionally family visa applicants.

If Schedule 3 applies, you’ll need to satisfy one of two paths:

1. Meet the Schedule 3 criteria strictly; or
2. Convince the Department of Home Affairs that there are compelling reasons to waive those requirements.

The Schedule 3 Criteria Explained

The specific criteria are found in clauses 3001 to 3004 of Schedule 3. They include:

• 3001: The visa application must be lodged within 28 days of the applicant becoming unlawful or their last visa ceasing.
• 3002: The applicant must not have been refused a visa or had a visa cancelled since last entering Australia.
• 3003: The applicant must demonstrate compelling reasons for the delay or unlawful status.
• 3004: The applicant must meet all standard visa requirements (health, character, financial ect.) despite the unlawful status.

If you fail to meet these clauses, your visa may be refused — unless the Department decides to waive Schedule 3.

Compelling Reasons: The Key to a Schedule 3 Waiver

Schedule 3 can be waived if there are “compelling reasons” for granting the visa despite the unlawful status.
This is a discretionary power held by the case officer — meaning your argument must be carefully prepared and well-documented.

Examples of “Compelling Reasons” That May Succeed

• You are in a genuine and ongoing relationship with an Australian partner, especially with children involved.
• You or your partner face significant hardship or medical issues if separated.
• The unlawful status resulted from exceptional circumstances beyond your control (e.g. serious illness, family tragedy, legal misadvice).
• You have made significant contributions to the Australian community, through work, volunteering, or caregiving.

What Usually Does Not Qualify

• Forgetting to renew a visa.
• Ignorance of visa expiry dates.
• Wanting to avoid the inconvenience or cost of applying offshore.

How Schedule 3 Can Impact Partner Visa Applicants

Partner visa applicants are the group most commonly affected by Schedule 3.
If your onshore partner visa application is lodged while you are unlawful or on a bridging visa, the Department will assess whether Schedule 3 applies.

If you cannot meet or waive Schedule 3, your visa will likely be refused, even if your relationship is genuine.

Therefore, preparing strong evidence and legal submissions explaining why the Department should exercise discretion is essential.

The Role of Legal Submissions and Evidence

A Schedule 3 waiver is not automatic — it must be requested and justified.
This typically involves:

1. Preparing a detailed written submission explaining the compelling reasons.
2. Providing supporting evidence, such as:
   • Medical reports
   • Relationship evidence (joint bills, photos, leases)
   • Character references
   • Statutory declarations outlining the timeline of events
3. Demonstrating how the refusal would cause significant hardship to you, your partner, or dependents.

In many cases, a migration lawyer can make a crucial difference by framing your circumstances persuasively under existing case law and policy guidelines.

Recent Trends: Tighter Schedule 3 Assessments

In recent years, the Department of Home Affairs has applied Schedule 3 more strictly.
Case officers now require clear, objective, and verifiable evidence before exercising discretion.
The “compelling reasons” threshold is interpreted narrowly, and applicants must present exceptional circumstances, not merely sympathetic ones.

Additionally, tribunals and courts have upheld that Schedule 3 should not be treated as a formality — it’s a core part of maintaining the integrity of Australia’s visa system.

Practical Strategies to Overcome Schedule 3 Risks

If you’re potentially affected by Schedule 3, here are key steps to take:

1. Seek Professional Advice Immediately

Engage a registered migration lawyer early — before lodging your application. They can identify if Schedule 3 applies and prepare arguments accordingly.

2. Lodge Within 28 Days (If Possible)

If your visa has expired, lodging your new application within 28 days of becoming unlawful can improve your position under Clause 3001.

3. Gather Compelling Evidence

Document all circumstances that explain your delay or unlawful status. Medical records, emails, or legal correspondence can help demonstrate genuine hardship.

4. Provide a Detailed Timeline

Show the Department that your unlawful period was short, unintentional, and justifiable based on the evidence.

5. Maintain Lawful Status Going Forward

Once your application is lodged, comply with all Bridging Visa A (BVA) conditions — including work and travel restrictions.

What Happens If Schedule 3 Is Not Waived?

If the Department refuses to waive Schedule 3, your visa will be refused.
However, you may have the right to appeal the decision to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) within the allowed time frame.

The Tribunal can review whether the Department correctly exercised discretion and consider new compelling evidence.
If successful, your case can be remitted to the Department for reassessment.

‍