Victorian Property: Easements & Covenants

When acquiring property in Victoria, buyers often focus on visible attributes like location, size, and building condition. However, hidden in the legal fabric of the land are crucial restrictions: easements and covenants. These legal instruments, though often overlooked, can profoundly impact property rights, usage, and value. Understanding them is paramount for anyone involved in a property transaction, from a first-time homeowner to a seasoned commercial property lawyer.

Fortunately, you can count on Integrity Alliance Trustable Lawyers provides essential guidance to identify, interpret, and manage these often-complex legal burdens, ensuring clients make informed decisions.

A property lawyer plays a critical role in unveiling these restrictions, which are typically registered on the property's Certificate of Title. Failure to identify and comprehend their implications can lead to unexpected limitations on development, usage disputes with neighbours or authorities, and a diminished property value.

What are Easements?

An easement is a right held by one party to use another person's land for a specific purpose, even though they do not own that land. In Victoria, easements "run with the land," meaning they are binding on successive owners. They are usually registered on the property title, indicating a defined area of the land subject to this right.

Common types of easements in Victoria include:

Right of Way Easements: These allow one landowner to pass over a portion of another's property to access their own, often seen in "battle-axe" blocks where one property is located behind another.

Utility Easements (or Service Easements): These grant public authorities (e.g., water, electricity, gas, telecommunications providers) the right to install, maintain, or repair infrastructure on a specific part of a property. For instance, a sewerage pipe might run underneath a backyard, restricting any building or substantial landscaping over that area.

Drainage Easements: Similar to utility easements, these permit the flow or drainage of water across a property, often for the benefit of neighbouring land or public storm water systems.

Easements for Support: Particularly relevant in urban areas with adjoining buildings, these ensure that one property provides structural support to a neighbouring building.

View Easements: Though less common, these can restrict what can be built or grown on a property to preserve a scenic view from another property.

The land that benefits from the easement is known as the "dominant tenement," while the land burdened by it is the "servient tenement." The owner of the servient land cannot interfere with the easement holder's right to use it. This limitation on the servient land's use can significantly affect its development potential and market appeal, often requiring a property lawyer in Sydney or property lawyer in Victoria to meticulously review.

What are Restrictive Covenants?

A restrictive covenant is a private agreement between landowners that imposes limitations on how a specific piece of land can be used or developed. Unlike easements, which grant a right of use, covenants restrict certain actions. Like easements, they typically "run with the land" and are registered on the property title, binding all future owners until they lapse or are formally removed.

Restrictive covenants are commonly created during subdivisions, where a developer imposes uniform conditions across all lots to maintain a particular character or amenity for the entire estate.

Examples frequently encountered in Victoria include:

• ‍Single Dwelling Restrictions: Prohibiting the construction of more than one dwelling on a lot, making dual occupancy or granny flats impossible without removal or variation.
• Building Material Requirements: Stipulating that a dwelling must be constructed using specific materials (e.g., brick, certain roofing types) to maintain a consistent aesthetic.‍
• Minimum Setback or Height Limits: Dictating how far a building must be from boundaries or limiting its maximum height.
• Use Restrictions: Prohibiting certain activities, such as running a commercial business lawyer near me office from a residential property, operating a workshop, or even keeping specific types of livestock.
• Minimum Value Covenants: Setting a minimum construction cost for any new dwelling, indexed to current values.

The land subject to the restrictions is the "burdened land," and the land that benefits from these restrictions (and whose owners can enforce them) is the "benefited land." A breach of a restrictive covenant can lead to legal action by the owners of the benefited land, potentially resulting in orders to cease the offending activity or even demolish non-compliant structures. This can quickly escalate into a property disputes.

How Easements and Covenants Affect Property Rights and Value in Victoria

The impact of easements and covenants on property rights and value in Victoria can be substantial and multifaceted:

Development Limitations: Both easements and covenants can severely restrict a property's development potential. An easement for sewerage, for example, may prevent the construction of a swimming pool or extension over that area. A restrictive covenant might prohibit subdivision or limit the number of dwellings, directly impacting a developer's plans or an owner's ability to maximise land use. This is a crucial consideration for any commercial lawyer advising on land acquisitions.

Impact on Usage and Enjoyment: A right of way easement might mean neighbours regularly traverse your land, affecting privacy and quiet enjoyment. A covenant might prevent a homeowner from running a small home-based business that is otherwise permitted by zoning, necessitating consultation with a commercial lawyer in Sydney.

Market Value: The presence and nature of these restrictions can influence a property's market value. Generally, more restrictive easements or covenants tend to decrease value, as they limit potential uses or impose ongoing obligations. For instance, a commercial property lawyer assessing a site for a new business development would weigh the impact of any registered easements or restrictive covenants on the viability and profitability of the project. Properties free from onerous restrictions are often more attractive to a broader range of buyers.

Maintenance Obligations: Some easements, such as shared driveways, come with shared maintenance responsibilities and costs, which can be an unexpected burden for a new owner.

Financing Challenges: Banks and lenders consider these restrictions during valuation. Highly restrictive covenants or easements that significantly diminish a property's utility could impact loan approvals or valuations.

Dispute Potential: Ambiguous terms, non-compliance, or perceived interference with rights can easily lead to property dispute lawyer actions between neighbours, utility providers, or even within an owners corporation. Such disputes can be costly and protracted, potentially requiring the intervention of a commercial disputes lawyer.

IATL's Role in Managing Legal Restrictions During Property Transactions

Understanding and managing easements and covenants is a specialised area of lawyer conveyancing that requires meticulous attention to detail and a deep understanding of Victorian property law. IATL's expertise is invaluable for clients navigating these complexities:

• ‍Thorough Due Diligence and Title Searches: Before any contract is signed, IATL conducts comprehensive due diligence. This begins with a detailed review of the Certificate of Title and the Section 32 Statement (Vendor's Statement) for any registered easements or restrictive covenants. We don't just identify their existence; we obtain and interpret the full text of these instruments, as their exact wording determines the scope of the restriction or right. This forensic approach is paramount to uncover all relevant legal encumbrances. For a client looking at property lawyer in Sydney services, a similar diligence is performed according to NSW law.‍‍

• ‍Expert Interpretation and Advice: The legal language of easements and covenants can be archaic and challenging to understand for non-legal professionals. Our conveyancing lawyer team translates these complex legal terms into plain English, clearly explaining how each restriction affects the client's proposed use of the property. For a developer, this might involve advising on whether a single dwelling covenant prohibits a planned multi-unit development. For a business owner, it could mean clarifying if a restrictive covenant prevents setting up a commercial venture from a residential address. Our advice clarifies limitations on building, extensions, renovations, and any ongoing obligations.‍

• Risk Assessment and Negotiation Support: Once identified and interpreted, IATL assesses the practical implications and potential risks associated with each easement or covenant. We advise clients on how these restrictions might impact their plans for the property, its future marketability, and any potential for property dispute lawyer actions. If a restriction poses a significant issue, we can advise on strategies to negotiate with the seller or relevant authorities. For example, it might be possible to obtain a planning permit to vary or remove a covenant under certain conditions, or negotiate with a utility provider to relocate an easement. This proactive negotiation can save significant time and money post-purchase.‍

• Assistance with Variation and Removal: Where an easement or covenant presents an unacceptable burden, IATL can guide clients through the formal legal processes for its variation or removal. In Victoria, this can involve:‍

• Application to the Supreme Court of Victoria: Under Section 84 of the Property Law Act 1958, the Supreme Court has the power to discharge or modify covenants on grounds such as obsolescence, unreasonable impediment to reasonable use, or consent of beneficiaries. This is often a complex and costly process.‍

• Planning Permit Application: For covenants created after 1991, or with the consent of all beneficiaries, a planning permit application to the local council (under Clause 52.02 of the Victorian Planning Provisions) may be possible.‍

• Agreement with Beneficiaries: For both easements and covenants, mutual agreement with all benefiting parties to extinguish or vary the restriction, followed by formal registration with Land Use Victoria, is often the most straightforward, though not always achievable, path.‍

• Subdivision Act Procedures: Easements and restrictions can sometimes be created, varied, or removed as part of a plan of subdivision or consolidation lodged with Land Use Victoria. Our lawyers possess the expertise to assess the most viable pathway for variation or removal, manage the application process, and represent clients in any necessary negotiations or tribunal hearings.‍

• Integrated Legal Solutions: IATL’s broad expertise ensures comprehensive support. For clients acquiring commercial property lawyer services, understanding property restrictions ties directly into commercial viability. Similarly, a conveyancing lawyer in Sydney or Victoria would provide transparent service agreements, ensuring their clients understand all fees and processes involved, adhering to consumer protection laws. Our commercial lawyer in Australia team is well-versed in how property restrictions can affect business operations, from expansion plans to leasing arrangements, often overlapping with the advice provided by a commercial lease lawyer.

Easements and covenants are silent yet powerful forces shaping property rights and value in Victoria. They represent enduring legal obligations or restrictions that can significantly impact a property owner's ability to use, develop, or sell their land. Overlooking these critical details during a property transaction can lead to unforeseen complications, costly disputes, and diminished investment potential.

‍